Checked against MLB.com and team sources on November 16, 2026: the two 2026 Cy Young Award winners were both unanimous, and neither was a first-round pick. If you are weighing a junior college offer, a mid-major scholarship or a bigger program for your son, that is worth a close look.
What the voters decided
According to MLB.com's Cy Young coverage, the BBWAA revealed the winners on Wednesday night, which was November 11. MLB.com's finalists story had listed Nov. 11 as the announcement date. Jacob Misiorowski of the Milwaukee Brewers won the National League award unanimously. Cam Schlittler of the New York Yankees won the American League award, also unanimously.
MLB.com lists Misiorowski at a 1.80 ERA with 252 strikeouts over 174 2/3 innings in 30 starts. It lists Schlittler at a 1.95 ERA, the best in the American League. The same article notes that Misiorowski set a record for the fastest pitch by a starter at 105.5 mph.
Two different roads to the same award
Misiorowski was a second-round pick in 2022 out of a Missouri junior college. Yahoo Sports' draft-day report identifies the school as Crowder College and says the Brewers took him 63rd overall. It says he had signed to continue at LSU and that he was the highest-drafted player in Crowder history. It lists his junior college season as 10-0 with a 2.72 ERA and 136 strikeouts in 76 innings.
Schlittler was a seventh-round pick in 2022 out of Northeastern. Northeastern's athletics site reports he went 220th overall to the Yankees, and that he was the school's highest pick since Aaron Civale in 2016. As a redshirt sophomore he had a 3.53 ERA over 15 starts. The same page says he entered that season as a preseason All-American.
So one came through a two-year school with a four-year commitment waiting, and the other through a Northeastern program that is a respected college team but not one of the national powers. Neither fits the first-round-name story most families picture when they think about the draft.
What this does and does not prove
Two pitchers do not make a trend. They are also, by definition, the exceptions: of the many players who take a junior college or mid-major road, very few end up winning a Cy Young. We are not claiming the path is easy or common, and we have no data on how often it works.
What the two stories do show is narrower and more useful. Draft position on one day in July did not decide what these players became. Both kept getting developed after they were picked, and both clearly improved a great deal. Where a player starts is a poor predictor of where he finishes, so a family does not need to treat a first offer, or the lack of one, as a verdict.
What to weigh if your son is choosing a path
Junior college
A junior college can give a player more innings, more at-bats and a second chance to be seen. Misiorowski's Crowder season shows what that can look like. The tradeoff is that the clock is shorter and you need a plan for the next step, whether that is a transfer to a four-year school or the draft. Ask each program where its players have gone in the last few years, and ask for names you can call.
Mid-major college
A program like Northeastern can offer steady playing time and coaching from day one, and a good player there can still be seen by scouts. Ask how many players the program has had drafted, how pitchers are developed, and whether the coaches will tell you honestly where your son fits.
The draft itself
A pick is the start of a development job, not the end of a recruiting one. Before any decision, learn what draft rank signals actually mean. We wrote about that in what being named to an MLB draft board means, and the earlier steps are laid out in our high school to college baseball recruiting timeline.
Why CageList exists
Most families cannot see the path. They see the first-round names on TV, and they do not see the junior college innings, the mid-major bullpens or the coaches who help a player pick a road. That information lives in scattered conversations, and it is hardest to find for families with no one in baseball to ask. CageList is trying to make that map easier to read: real coaches you can look at, and a place to start with college baseball recruiting help.
Frequently asked questions
Who won the 2026 Cy Young Awards?
Per MLB.com, Jacob Misiorowski of the Brewers won the National League award and Cam Schlittler of the Yankees won the American League award. Both were unanimous.
Was Jacob Misiorowski drafted out of a junior college?
Yes. Yahoo Sports reported he was a second-round pick, 63rd overall, in 2022 out of Crowder College, a Missouri junior college.
Was Cam Schlittler a first-round pick?
No. Northeastern's athletics site reports he was taken in the seventh round, 220th overall, by the Yankees in 2022.
Is junior college to MLB a realistic path?
It is a real path, and Misiorowski's career proves it can work. It is not a common one, and we have no numbers on how many players follow it. Treat it as one legitimate option to weigh, not a plan to count on.
Turn the talk into reps
Every one of these comes back to the same thing: getting on the field and putting in the work. Find cage time near you and go do it.
Related Guides
View all articlesRun a travel team? Get your free page.
Baseball or softball. Claim a free directory page, post tryouts, and share cagelist.com/@yourteam with families.
Find your league
Free directories of real leagues and clubs near you. Then book a batting cage to get your reps in before opening day.
1,893 organizations
leagues in 49 statesAdult hardball near you: MSBL, NABA and independent leagues.Browse men's leagues
leagues in 49 statesYouth baseball and softball leagues, organized by state.Browse little leagues
programs in 41 statesTravel and club programs in your region. Find one, or list yours free.Browse travel teamsJoin the backyard batting cage community
Talk builds, gear, hosting and player development with cage owners, coaches, parents and baseball families.



